Perspectives

The View from Next Street

A sharing of ideas and policy perspectives.

 

I had the pleasure to appear at the Poverty, Justice and Jobs Think Tank, hosted by Harvard University’s Advanced Leadership Initiative in association with the Charles Hamilton Houston Institute for Race & Justice. The panel, titled Economic Empowerment and Job Creation: Microfinance and Enterprise Solutions, was moderated by Harvard Business School’s Peter Tufano and included Michael Chu, Senior Lecturer, Harvard Business School; Nancy Barry, former CEO, Women’s World Banking; Gail Snowden, CEO, Freedom House; Andrea Titterington, Regeneration Director, Liverpool Football Club; and Tim Williamson, Co-Founder and CEO, Idea Village.

Tim Ferguson

printEconomic Empowerment and Job Creation: Microfinance and Enterprise Solutions

Poverty, Justice and Jobs Think Tank, Harvard University

 

Here’s the problem, as I see it: Our attention – our focus – is not where it should be.

Michael Porter has said that no social program can rival the business sector when it comes to creating the jobs, wealth, and innovation that improve standards of living and social conditions over time. And yet so much of our focus is either on big business on the one hand, philanthropy and micro-finance on the other, that we essentially neglect – some of it’s benign, some not – that part of the business sector that is most productive, creates the most jobs, represents the fundamental drivers of our economy.

I’m talking about the missing middle. Those businesses that James Surowiecki described in The New Yorker as bigger than a fruit stand but smaller than a Fortune 1000 corporation. They have revenues between $1 million and $100 million, and are responsible for more than 60 percent of all jobs, making them absolutely essential to our economic prosperity.

Ironically, they are more or less ignored by traditional financial institutions and are barely on the radar of VCs or foundations. Sustained economic growth requires businesses like these that reach for scale. It requires that we invest in resources that help build and support them, and in so doing, provide momentum for job growth and wealth creation. And yet our tendency is to ignore these innovative, hard-working, persevering and profitable entrepreneurs, and we continue to do so at our collective risk.

I am extremely passionate about this, so much so that I founded Next Street, a merchant bank dedicated to providing advice and access to capital to urban-based, small and medium sized businesses. In fact, Next Street’s model represents a new enterprise for a new economy: a for-profit business focused on maximizing the growth, profitability and success of high-performing urban businesses. Our goal is nothing less than enhancing economic development, wealth and job creation and transforming the way that financial and business advisory services are provided in this market.

Our client businesses are often – but not always – minority or women owned. They’re creating real jobs, the kind of careers you can raise a family on, and improve standards of living that build up communities.

When I talk about this sector, I realize that it doesn’t have the inherent sexiness of a celebrity-backed charity or micro-finance project, or the obvious appeal for big banks or VCs. But in fact these businesses should be very appealing to all of these investor groups. Unfortunately, there exists a bias against these businesses that leads not only to neglect, but actual barriers to their growth. Whatever the root of this bias, it’s certainly not based on reason. And here’s why:

The majority of Next Street’s clients have been around an average of 18 years. They’ve weathered recessions and national catastrophes, and continue to open their doors each day. This says that their success isn’t fleeting.

These companies are typically smaller but more profitable than the average small business, and 50 percent less likely to default on their debt than the average small business, and one-third less likely than a large business.

And while minority-owned businesses grew twice as fast as all others during the last decade, bank loan denial rates are five to six times higher for ethnic-and minority-owned businesses, the majority of which are located in our cities. Five to six times more likely to be turned away. It makes no sense at all.

Some barriers are definitely attitudinal, such as misperceptions about the risk of investing in urban companies. Others are systemic, such as the dwindling availability of loans from the Small Business Administration.

But the major barriers are related to the changes in the banking world over the last 25 years: from consolidation, to the decline in relationship management, to loan practices designed for much larger businesses in order to facilitate economies of scale.

The large foundations have a critical role to play here but, for a variety of reasons, they haven’t stepped up. I have nothing against philanthropy, mind you. I sit on the boards of numerous not-for-profits. And here’s what I see: organizations view their grant-making and their endowment investing as mutually exclusive, with little if any effort toward coordinating foundation investments with their missions. In fact, foundation investments have sometimes worked against the goals supported by grants and programs.

As for microfinance, it can make tremendous differences in the lives of individuals. No question. But neither charity nor micro-finance can build economies. If we want to really accomplish things on a meaningful scale, we need to redirect our attention and reconsider where we direct our investments.

So from our point-of-view, we see big banks and venture capitalists over here; mission investing – as it’s currently practiced – and small-bore government and not-for-profit initiatives over here. In the middle is what we call the Imagination Gap because of the apparent failure of investors to see that here is where true opportunities lie.

New Enterprises for a New Economy
Why a merchant bank? As Jeff Swartz of Timberland says, just as VC firms have geniuses in residence, entrepreneurs need access to venture wisdom. In addition to finance, merchant bankers are providers of ‘the wisdom stuff’. By definition, merchant banks are versatile and willing to change with their clients.

For example, we discovered early on that, in addition to financing and strategic advice, many of our clients also need advertising and marketing services, and so we developed a practice to address that need, called Next Street Agency. Others sought talent management advice, and we now provide that as well.

Mae West once said “Marriage is a fine institution. I’m just not ready for an institution.” Nor should any of us be. We need to stop thinking like institutions, and return to thinking like innovators. Instead, what I’m seeing is short-sightedness across-the-board, from the large, traditional financial institutions to the philanthropic sector to government spending. Indeed, we have yet to see how much of the stimulus package actually trickles down to the kinds of businesses I’m talking about.

For instance, at Next Street we spend a lot of time talking to investors about what we’re doing. But accepted traditional thinking is so segmented that they find us confounding. Invariably, they try to fit us into one of their pre-defined buckets. But they can’t. And as a result they have no idea what to do with us.

So we’ve made it easy. We’ve established two funds that allow them to invest directly in these companies. And as we build our capital base, we anticipate the impact, in terms of job creation, to be substantial. Because, bottom line: that’s how we measure success. By jobs created. By communities at work. As my partner Ron Walker often says, ultimately the best social program is a job. In five years’ time, our goal is to have committed capital in excess of $1 billion, supporting over 500 inner city small businesses nationally, resulting in the creation of 12,000 new jobs.

In order to make this happen we need investors to think out of the box, and embrace a willingness to build and support new enterprises like Next Street. The new economy demands it. To quote President Obama: “Our recovery in the present and our prosperity in the future depend upon the success of America’s small businesses and entrepreneurs.”

Looking Forward
So here’s where I see room for improvement:

Traditional financial institutions need to return risk to the market, but be responsible about it. Build relationships with small businesses and non-profits, get to know them, get to know how they operate, and judge them by their promise as well as their past. Many of our greatest, most lauded enterprises would not exist today if some banker hadn’t taken a well-founded risk. Currently, large banks do not understand the needs of this segment and are in no position to give them what they need. They don’t even know who they are. We do.

Regarding endowment investment funds, foundations need to understand that for-profits like Next Street can have a double bottom line; that they can do good and do well. The Annie E. Casey Foundation, for instance, does this. It’s made a point of aligning both its program and investment initiatives so that each supports the other. Philanthropic foundations are among the world’s leading institutional investors, currently holding more than $600 billion in assets in the U.S. alone. And yet, less than one-twentieth of one percent goes toward mission investing. This represents a tremendous missed opportunity.

As microfinance emphasizes individual entrepreneurship it, by nature, generates a relatively small number of jobs. In recognition of this, just last year three prominent foundations began an investment company that actually targets businesses trapped in the missing middle. But they’re doing it in India. We need to bring more efforts like this to bear here at home.

It seems we’re all too willing to go anywhere, seek out any opportunity, so long as we don’t have to go into America’s urban centers. We do not need to travel the world in search of investment opportunities that have social impact. We can do that right in our own back yard.

Across the country, the opportunity is real. I invite anyone who cares about our national prosperity to seek out the missing middle, wherein lies innovation, job creation, sustainability, and long-term opportunities for growth.

 
SHOW COMPLETE TEXT

New Enterprises for a New Economy
Why a merchant bank? As Jeff Swartz of Timberland says, just as VC firms have geniuses in residence, entrepreneurs need access to venture wisdom. In addition to finance, merchant bankers are providers of ‘the wisdom stuff’. By definition, merchant banks are versatile and willing to change with their clients.

For example, we discovered early on that, in addition to financing and strategic advice, many of our clients also need advertising and marketing services, and so we developed a practice to address that need, called Next Street Agency. Others sought talent management advice, and we now provide that as well.

Mae West once said “Marriage is a fine institution. I’m just not ready for an institution.” Nor should any of us be. We need to stop thinking like institutions, and return to thinking like innovators. Instead, what I’m seeing is short-sightedness across-the-board, from the large, traditional financial institutions to the philanthropic sector to government spending. Indeed, we have yet to see how much of the stimulus package actually trickles down to the kinds of businesses I’m talking about.

For instance, at Next Street we spend a lot of time talking to investors about what we’re doing. But accepted traditional thinking is so segmented that they find us confounding. Invariably, they try to fit us into one of their pre-defined buckets. But they can’t. And as a result they have no idea what to do with us.

So we’ve made it easy. We’ve established two funds that allow them to invest directly in these companies. And as we build our capital base, we anticipate the impact, in terms of job creation, to be substantial. Because, bottom line: that’s how we measure success. By jobs created. By communities at work. As my partner Ron Walker often says, ultimately the best social program is a job. In five years’ time, our goal is to have committed capital in excess of $1 billion, supporting over 500 inner city small businesses nationally, resulting in the creation of 12,000 new jobs.

In order to make this happen we need investors to think out of the box, and embrace a willingness to build and support new enterprises like Next Street. The new economy demands it. To quote President Obama: “Our recovery in the present and our prosperity in the future depend upon the success of America’s small businesses and entrepreneurs.”

Looking Forward
So here’s where I see room for improvement:

Traditional financial institutions need to return risk to the market, but be responsible about it. Build relationships with small businesses and non-profits, get to know them, get to know how they operate, and judge them by their promise as well as their past. Many of our greatest, most lauded enterprises would not exist today if some banker hadn’t taken a well-founded risk. Currently, large banks do not understand the needs of this segment and are in no position to give them what they need. They don’t even know who they are. We do.

Regarding endowment investment funds, foundations need to understand that for-profits like Next Street can have a double bottom line; that they can do good and do well. The Annie E. Casey Foundation, for instance, does this. It’s made a point of aligning both its program and investment initiatives so that each supports the other. Philanthropic foundations are among the world’s leading institutional investors, currently holding more than $600 billion in assets in the U.S. alone. And yet, less than one-twentieth of one percent goes toward mission investing. This represents a tremendous missed opportunity.

As microfinance emphasizes individual entrepreneurship it, by nature, generates a relatively small number of jobs. In recognition of this, just last year three prominent foundations began an investment company that actually targets businesses trapped in the missing middle. But they’re doing it in India. We need to bring more efforts like this to bear here at home.

It seems we’re all too willing to go anywhere, seek out any opportunity, so long as we don’t have to go into America’s urban centers. We do not need to travel the world in search of investment opportunities that have social impact. We can do that right in our own back yard.

Across the country, the opportunity is real. I invite anyone who cares about our national prosperity to seek out the missing middle, wherein lies innovation, job creation, sustainability, and long-term opportunities for growth.

Printed on Thursday, February 23, 2012
http://www.nextstreet.com/public_sector_initiatives/ideas_and_policy_perspective/economic_empowerment_and_job_creation_microfinance_and_enterprise_solutions